Skip to content
Technology

Musician Challenges Automated Copyright Takedown by AI-Driven Firm

A songwriter successfully fought to restore her work after a digital distributor used automated tools to claim ownership of her original performance.

By 3 min read

Musician Samantha Shokin recently faced a protracted struggle to restore her own vocal recording to YouTube after a company called Media Nov Records issued a copyright strike against it. The dispute centered on a 50-second a cappella cover of the public domain Bulgarian folk song 'Bre Petrunko,' which Shokin had recorded during the pandemic. Despite her clear ownership of the performance, YouTube’s automated system rejected two of her counterclaims, leaving her unable to reach a human representative to resolve the error.

The conflict began when Shokin discovered that her recording had been widely sampled by electronic music producers without her permission. She traced the audio to a sample pack sold by Loopmasters, which subsequently apologized and agreed to pay royalties. However, the situation escalated months later when Media Nov Records, a separate distribution firm, claimed copyright over her original video. The company’s website advertises services including AI-powered content recognition and automated DMCA takedowns, claiming to manage 500 YouTube channels.

Media Nov Records, which corporate filings suggest was established approximately one year ago, initially ignored Shokin’s attempts to contact them. The company’s online presence is characterized by hundreds of videos featuring AI-generated imagery and looping electronic music, often garnering low engagement. When questioned by reporters, the company claimed that Shokin’s correspondence had been directed to a spam folder and demanded she provide documentation to prove her ownership of the recording.

In its communication, Media Nov Records attempted to distinguish between the rights of the folk song composition and the individual sound recording, referencing a 1963 version of the song by composer Philip Koutev. However, the company failed to identify which specific work in its catalog had allegedly been infringed by Shokin’s performance. Legal experts noted that the firm’s actions appeared to be part of a broader, aggressive strategy of using automated tools to issue copyright claims, potentially overreaching the rights they actually possess.

Alfred Steiner, an attorney specializing in copyright law, suggested that the incident reflects a systemic issue where understaffed companies use automated systems to file mass takedown requests. 'It sounds, to me, like a small company... that are understaffed and is using a lot of different tools, probably a lot of AI, to identify tracks that are ostensibly owned by its clients and then automatically filing takedown requests,' Steiner observed. He added that such 'shotgun' approaches to copyright enforcement can cause significant harm to independent creators who lack the resources to challenge them.

Following inquiries from the media, Media Nov Records withdrew its copyright claim, stating that it did not consider the removal necessary because the video was not generating revenue. The company maintained that it was not waiving any potential rights and intended to pursue the matter legally. YouTube subsequently confirmed the restoration of Shokin’s video. Reflecting on the ordeal, Shokin expressed frustration that the platform’s automated systems failed to protect her rights, forcing her to rely on external intervention to achieve a resolution.

Sources

Related stories