Environmental Investigation Launched After Pesticide Spraying in Monterrey Park
Authorities and activists are scrutinizing the impact of chemical spraying on migrating monarch butterflies during a local legislator's event.
A public park in Monterrey, Mexico, has become the center of an environmental controversy after a local legislator’s team conducted a fumigation process in an area currently serving as a resting point for migrating monarch butterflies. The incident, which occurred on November 12 at the Rincón de los Encinos park, took place ahead of a public health event organized by Lorena de la Garza Venecia, a member of the Nuevo León state legislature.
The fumigation, intended to combat mosquitoes ahead of a dengue vaccination drive, drew immediate backlash from citizens and environmental activists who reported seeing dead butterflies on the ground shortly after the chemicals were applied. The monarch butterfly is a protected species in Mexico under the NOM-059-SEMARNAT-2010 standard, and its annual migration from Canada and the United States is considered a vital ecological event.
Lorena de la Garza Venecia has publicly apologized for the incident, acknowledging that the fumigation was an error that should not have occurred during the butterflies' migratory passage. The legislator stated that the application covered approximately 40 square meters and lasted five minutes. She maintained that her team consulted with a biologist to mitigate potential harm and asserted that no dead or affected butterflies were found in the area following the application.
Despite the legislator's explanation, the incident has sparked significant public outcry. A petition on Change.org calling for her removal from office has garnered tens of thousands of signatures. Activist Arturo Islas Allende has been a vocal critic of the event, filing formal complaints with the Federal Attorney for Environmental Protection (Profepa) and the Attorney General's Office (FGR). Islas Allende argued that the legislator lacked the authority to conduct such operations and warned that pesticide exposure can have delayed, lethal effects on the insects.
The Federal Attorney for Environmental Protection (Profepa) has intervened by conducting an inspection of the site. The agency ordered an immediate suspension of all fumigation activities and prohibited any pruning, washing, or alteration of the park. Furthermore, the agency has mandated that the responsible parties submit a detailed map of the application area and a remediation plan within 48 hours to address potential environmental damages.
State authorities, including the agency Parques y Vida Silvestre de Nuevo León, are also building a legal case to determine accountability. They are currently coordinating with the municipal government and health officials to identify the specific chemicals used and to assess the long-term impact on the local ecosystem. While the legislator has pledged to cooperate with the investigation and review her team's protocols, the incident has reignited a broader conversation regarding the protection of migratory corridors in urban spaces.
Sources
- Diputada de Nuevo León sobre fumigación a mariposas monarcas tribunademexico.com
- Mariposas Monarca Mueren tras Fumigación en Parque para Evento en Monterrey: 'Fue un Error' | N+ nmas.com.mx
- Fumigan parque durante paso de mariposas monarca para mitin de diputada; ofrece disculpas mimorelia.com
- Exigen destitución de diputada tras fumigación en zona de descanso de mariposas monarca en Monterrey retodiario.com
- Diputada fumiga parque donde descansaban mariposas monarca diario.mx