Skip to content
Sports

Indiana Resident Fights Golf Club in Court Over Stray Balls

A property dispute in DeMotte over thousands of stray golf balls landing in a residential yard has reached the Indiana Supreme Court.

By 3 min read

A prolonged neighborhood dispute between an Indiana resident and a nearby golf club has landed before the Indiana Supreme Court, which heard oral arguments on October 29, 2026. The legal battle centers on Mitchell Schultz, a homeowner living in DeMotte in the northern part of the state, and the adjacent Sandy Pines Golf Club, whose driving range shares a boundary with his property.

The conflict began after the golf club opened a driving range for long-shot practice in 2018. According to estimates cited in the legal proceedings, roughly 1,500 stray golf balls have landed on Schultz's property each year since the opening. The barrage has caused property damage, including broken windows, and forced balls into the family swimming pool. In response, Schultz altered his daily routines, parking his vehicle at the far end of his garage and sheltering under a tent in the yard to avoid being struck.

The family has owned the residential property for more than five decades, while the golf club purchased its land from Schultz's brother. In an effort to mitigate the issue, the club implemented lower-flight balls, instructed players not to hit over safety nets, and discouraged the use of hitting bays closest to the house. However, these measures failed to stop the influx of golf balls.

During initial litigation, the Jasper County Trial Court rejected claims of negligence and nuisance based on the "coming to the nuisance" doctrine, which suggests that individuals moving near an existing nuisance assume a portion of the risk. Although the trial judge ultimately found the club responsible for property trespass, the court assigned 95 percent of the blame to the homeowner, effectively eliminating any monetary damages.

In December 2025, the Indiana Court of Appeals unanimously reversed that decision, ruling that comparative fault cannot reduce liability for an intentional act. The case then escalated to the Indiana Supreme Court, where justices evaluated whether the golf club or individual patrons bear responsibility for the stray projectiles. Homeowner attorney Jacob Ahler stated that his client is not seeking financial compensation, but rather a judicial order to stop the balls from entering the property, which could involve taller protective nets or closing the driving range entirely.

Representing the golf club, attorney Donald Shelmon argued that each individual golfer is responsible for their own shots, noting that the facility operates with proper zoning authorization and contesting the volume of stray balls counted. Meanwhile, the justices questioned how fault could be assigned to a resident subjected to a continuous influx of golf balls, especially since the homeowner is seeking injunctive relief rather than financial damages.

The Indiana Supreme Court has yet to issue a final ruling. If the high court declines to review the case, the ruling from the Court of Appeals will stand, determining the outcome of the ongoing neighborhood conflict in DeMotte.

Sources

Related stories