Skip to content
Politics

Basic Education Director-General Sues Minister Siviwe Gwarube for R2 Million

Mathanzima Mweli is seeking damages and an apology over allegedly defamatory statements regarding a lifestyle audit.

By 3 min read

The Director-General of the Department of Basic Education, Mathanzima Mweli, has initiated legal action to claim R2 million in general damages from Basic Education Minister Siviwe Gwarube and her spokesperson, Lukhanyo Vangqa. Law firm Xuba and Associates released a statement on Wednesday confirming that a notice to institute the damages claim has been issued following public comments about Mweli and a Special Investigating Unit lifestyle audit.

The legal dispute follows a media report published on September 13 in the Sunday Times and TimesLIVE. In the report, Vangqa was quoted stating that because the director-general handles billions of rands in public procurement, he must be beyond reproach. Vangqa reportedly added that refusing to undergo a lifestyle audit leaves uncomfortable questions and creates an intolerable risk to public funds.

Mweli's legal representatives argued that the statements were wrongful and defamatory, conveying that their client's honesty, integrity, and trustworthiness in administering public funds were questionable. The lawsuit names Gwarube as the nominal defendant of the state and Vangqa in his personal capacity due to vicarious liability. Alongside financial damages, Mweli is demanding a public retraction, a correction of the statements, and an apology.

Responding to the development, Vangqa stated that the minister had not yet received formal court papers, adding that the lawsuit would be fully defended if received. Vangqa further described the intended legal action as vexatious and without merit, emphasizing that senior managers in the department must subject themselves to lifestyle audits in line with government policy.

Vangqa noted that Minister Gwarube has undergone a similar process and remains determined to see the Special Investigating Unit lifestyle audit through. Meanwhile, Mweli's lawyers maintained that their client is not opposed to lawful lifestyle audits but objects to procedures they view as unlawful and lacking proper confidentiality, fairness, and independence safeguards.

In a separate development concerning the Department of Basic Education, Minister Gwarube recently warned that the current pace of vetting educators is unlikely to meet the March deadline for checking all school staff against the National Child Protection Register. Parliament was informed that only about 20% of educators have been vetted since a court-ordered mandate was issued.

Addressing a portfolio committee, Gwarube stated that the slow progress is insufficient and announced plans to convene a meeting later this month to evaluate the support needed to accelerate the vetting process. The vetting chain involves criminal checks by the police, child protection register checks by the Department of Social Development, and sexual offender register reviews managed by the Department of Justice.

Sources

Related stories