Skip to content
Politics

Lawsuit Filed to Block HUD Rule on Public Housing Immigration Status

A nonprofit law firm is challenging a federal mandate that would require all public housing residents to provide proof of legal immigration status.

By 3 min read

Public Counsel, a Los Angeles-based nonprofit law firm, filed a lawsuit in federal court late Monday to block a new U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD) rule. The regulation, scheduled to take effect in mid-December, mandates that every individual residing in federally funded public housing must provide proof of qualifying immigration status to remain in their homes.

The legal challenge aims to halt a significant shift in policy that departs from a decades-long practice. Previously, families with mixed immigration statuses were permitted to live together in subsidized housing, with rent costs prorated to account for members who were ineligible for federal assistance. Under the new rule, individuals who lack specific legal status, such as citizenship or asylum, would be disqualified from residing in these units.

Attorneys representing the plaintiffs argue that HUD lacks the legal authority to implement such a change, asserting that this power rests solely with Congress. The lawsuit was filed on behalf of three anonymous individuals currently living in public housing in Los Angeles. One plaintiff, identified as a 24-year-old pharmacy technician, expressed deep concern over the potential for family separation, noting that her parents are undocumented while she and her siblings are U.S. citizens.

Data from the Housing Authority of the City of Los Angeles (HACLA) indicates that approximately 7,700 individuals in the city live in mixed-status households. Across the United States, HUD estimates that there were 79,300 members of mixed-status families living in public housing as of 2024. The agency has maintained that while ineligible residents do not receive rental discounts, they do not possess a right to occupy publicly funded housing.

HUD officials have defended the policy as a necessary measure to prioritize resources for citizens and eligible residents. In a statement, HUD Secretary Scott Turner characterized the previous arrangement as an exploitation of government-funded programs, stating that American taxpayers should not be responsible for the costs associated with ineligible individuals. The agency has suggested that the fear of family separation might lead many mixed-status families to voluntarily depart from public housing.

Critics of the rule, including the legal team at Public Counsel, warn that the mandate could exacerbate the existing affordable housing crisis. They argue that displacing these families will increase the demand for shelters and other social services, creating a broader impact on the community. HACLA has stated that it is currently reviewing the final regulation to assess its operational requirements and compliance timelines as the mid-December deadline approaches.

Sources

Related stories