Skip to content
World

Former Nun Back on Trial in Portugal Over Alleged Embezzlement

Idalina Joaquim returned to court after an appeals court annulled her previous 2024 acquittal regarding the disappearance of 360,000 euros.

By 2 min read

An 81-year-old former nun returned to the defendant's bench in Bragança, Portugal, on Tuesday to face a retrial over accusations that she misappropriated 360,000 euros from a social center. Idalina Joaquim, who served as the treasurer for the Centro Social e Paroquial dos Cerejais in Alfândega da Fé, was previously acquitted of two counts of breach of trust and one count of qualified theft in late 2024.

However, the Guimarães Court of Appeal subsequently annulled that initial sentence, ruling that there were legal flaws and insufficient reasoning in the first-instance verdict. The appellate court ordered the same panel of judges in Bragança to reopen the case and re-examine financial transfers and withdrawals linked to the institution.

During Tuesday's court session, the former religious sister declined to make any statements. Her defense counsel cited "profound memory lapses" and requested that she be excused from attending future scheduled hearings.

The ongoing legal proceedings focus on financial irregularities allegedly committed between 2007 and 2010. Prosecutors originally charged that funds from resident fees and donations were diverted from the social center into accounts belonging to the former treasurer and her siblings.

During the initial trial, the court in Bragança concluded it was not proven that the defendant had personally benefited from the transactions or that she acted as a front for the late priest Father Manuel Joaquim Ochôa, who founded the institution. The judges previously determined that the various account movements appeared to be coordinated by the clergyman rather than an identified individual.

The opening day of the retrial featured testimony from Social Security inspectors who conducted audits of the facility in 2011 and 2012 following external complaints. The inspectors reaffirmed findings from their original reports, detailing several administrative discrepancies.

According to the audit testimonies, resident fees collected by the nursing home were not entirely deposited into the official accounts of the center. Furthermore, inspectors identified expense notes signed by Father Ochôa that lacked specific monetary values or recipient names, alongside discrepancies between financial statements and bank balances provided by the accountant.

Before her legal troubles began, the defendant spent decades within the church. She arrived at Cerejais in 1985, wore the habit for 45 years, and eventually attained the position of mother superior before being expelled and stripped of her religious status as the investigation unfolded.

Sources

Related stories