Alex Murdaugh's Lawyers Ask Judge to Dismiss 2021 Murder Indictments
Defense attorneys argue that the chief investigator in the case lied to the grand jury ahead of an upcoming retrial.
Attorneys for Alex Murdaugh appeared in court on Friday to ask a judge to throw out the original murder indictments stemming from the 2021 killings of his wife and son. The defense team argues that the lead investigator in the case provided false information to the grand jury.
Murdaugh is currently preparing for a retrial on the murder charges after the South Carolina Supreme Court overturned his previous convictions and life sentence. The high court ruled that a court clerk improperly influenced jurors during his high-profile 2023 trial.
During Friday's pretrial hearing before Judge Debra McCaslin, defense lawyers stated that State Law Enforcement Division agent David Owen misled the Colleton County grand jury. According to the defense, Owen falsely claimed that blood spatter was discovered on a T-shirt Murdaugh wore on the night of the killings, despite an earlier state report finding no blood stains and no such evidence being presented at trial.
Defense attorneys also noted that Owen incorrectly told grand jurors that the exact ammunition configuration used to kill Paul Murdaugh—buckshot in one chamber and large birdshot in the other—was found in weapons throughout the family's property. Owen has acknowledged making mistakes during the investigation, but denied intentionally misleading the grand jury.
Even if Judge McCaslin grants the defense request to dismiss the indictments, legal experts suggest it may not delay the scheduled April retrial. Prosecutors retain the authority to seek a new set of grand jury indictments as soon as next month, a move defense attorneys indicated they do not plan to block.
Prosecutors defended their case by asserting they possess substantial other evidence supporting the charges against Murdaugh. They argued in court filings that "a single mistake is not bad faith" and highlighted evidence including a video recorded by Paul Murdaugh that featured his father's voice at the crime scene, as well as mounting financial debts and unfolding theft schemes.
Legal analyst Jessica Levinson noted that a dismissal would not eliminate the prosecution's overall body of evidence. "Even if the defense is able to convince the judge that this chief investigator lied and the case should be dismissed, there's a lot of evidence here that does not relate to the chief investigator," Levinson told CBS Mornings. "I think the prosecution would likely feel that they could bring a very similar case to the jury, hoping they would get another conviction."
A ruling in favor of Murdaugh would represent a significant formal rebuke for Owen, who abruptly retired in 2024 shortly after receiving recognition as State Law Enforcement Officer of the Year. A separate murder case involving Owen was dismissed by a judge last year after he failed to relay information regarding a victim's suicide threat to prosecutors and defense attorneys.
Murdaugh, 58, is already serving a decades-long prison sentence for stealing millions of dollars from legal clients, and he has admitted in court to being a thief and opioid addict while continuing to deny involvement in the murders of his wife, Maggie, and younger son, Paul. Regardless of the outcome of the upcoming murder proceedings, Murdaugh will remain incarcerated.