Skip to content
Business

Supreme Court of Mexico Rules Against Double Pension Payments for IMSS Employees

The ruling clarifies that contractual retirement benefits for institute staff already include old-age pension coverage, prohibiting the collection of both simultaneously.

By 3 min read

The Supreme Court of Justice of the Nation (SCJN) in Mexico has issued a definitive ruling confirming that employees of the Mexican Social Security Institute (IMSS) cannot simultaneously receive both a contractual retirement pension and a legal old-age pension. The decision, handed down by the Court's Second Chamber, reinforces the financial stability of the institute by preventing what it describes as an unjustified duplication of benefits.

The legal conflict arose when former IMSS employees sought to collect two distinct payments upon retirement: the retirement pension for years of service, as stipulated in the collective bargaining agreement between the IMSS and the National Union of Social Security Workers (SNTSS), and the legal old-age pension provided under the Social Security Law. The court determined that the contractual retirement scheme is already comprehensive, effectively incorporating the benefits of the old-age pension.

Writing for the court, Minister Yasmín Esquivel Mossa noted that the collective bargaining agreement provides benefits that are superior to those mandated by law for the general workforce. Because the contractual retirement package already covers subsistence needs through higher payments and additional family assistance, the court concluded that the IMSS is only obligated to cover the difference required to reach that higher threshold rather than paying both amounts in full.

The ruling, specifically outlined in the Amparo Directo en Revisión 5192/2024, emphasizes that this decision does not violate the right to social security. The court argued that since the contractual retirement already includes the equivalent of old-age benefits, denying a second, separate payment prevents a double-dipping scenario that would place an unnecessary burden on the institute's finances.

It is important to note that this judicial precedent is narrow in scope. The ruling applies exclusively to IMSS workers governed by the specific Retirement and Pension Regime (RJP) established in their collective contract. It does not affect pensioned workers in the private sector, employees in other public sectors, or those covered under the 1973 and 1997 Social Security Laws. The court clarified that the decision does not cancel previously acquired rights for the general population or alter the requirements for standard retirement benefits.

The legal debate surrounding this issue has persisted for years, with the court previously addressing the incompatibility of these benefits in the 2013 contradiction of thesis 296/2013. The recent 2024 ruling reaffirmed this long-standing interpretation, ensuring that the criteria remain consistent. The court's decision serves as a final resolution for those who had hoped to supplement their retirement income by combining these two specific types of pension payments.

In the meantime, the IMSS has confirmed that the payment schedule for December 2026 remains unchanged. Pensioners are expected to receive their funds on Tuesday, December 1, through bank transfers or in-person collections. The institute advises beneficiaries to plan their visits to bank branches accordingly to avoid the high demand typically seen at the start of each month. Those who encounter issues with their deposits are encouraged to contact the official IMSS support line or visit their local family medicine unit for assistance.

Sources

Related stories