Skip to content
Politics

Supreme Court Declines to Hear Challenge to California Medical Education Law

Justice Clarence Thomas warned that the decision could allow states to compel private speech under the guise of government regulation.

By 3 min read

The United States Supreme Court declined on Monday to hear a challenge to a California law that mandates continuing medical education courses for physicians include instruction on implicit bias. The case, brought by California ophthalmologist Dr. Azadeh Khatibi and the nonprofit organization Do No Harm, argued that the state requirement forces private instructors to convey a government-favored message in violation of the First Amendment.

Justice Clarence Thomas, joined by Justice Samuel Alito, dissented from the court's decision to deny the petition. In his written dissent, Thomas expressed concern that the lower court's ruling, which categorized these medical courses as government speech, could set a dangerous precedent. He argued that the government-speech doctrine should not be used as a cover for censorship or a means to compel private citizens to act as mouthpieces for state-mandated viewpoints.

The dispute centers on California's requirement that licensed physicians complete 50 hours of state-approved continuing education every two years, with specific instruction on how implicit bias affects health outcomes. Dr. Khatibi and her legal team contended that the topic is not relevant to her specific courses and that she disagrees with the premise that implicit bias is the primary driver of healthcare disparities. They argued that the mandate forces instructors to spend limited time on content they do not support.

The state of California defended the law by asserting that while instructors must include the topic of implicit bias, they are not required to personally endorse the theory. The state argued that instructors remain free to express their disagreement with the concept or to inform attendees that the discussion is included solely to comply with regulatory requirements. Lower courts previously ruled that because California extensively regulates the medical profession, these courses constitute government speech rather than private expression, exempting them from standard First Amendment scrutiny.

Justice Thomas challenged this characterization, warning that the logic applied by the Ninth Circuit could have far-reaching implications for other professions. He hypothesized whether the state could similarly compel speakers at legal conferences to adopt specific stances on hiring practices or other controversial social issues. He noted that if enough government regulation is sufficient to convert private speech into government speech, it could undermine constitutional protections for professionals across various fields.

Beyond the immediate context of implicit bias training, Thomas suggested the precedent could be used to compel speech on sensitive topics such as abortion or gender-transition surgery. He pointed to previous Supreme Court rulings, including the 2018 decision in National Institute of Family and Life Advocates v. Becerra, where the court protected pregnancy centers from being forced to refer patients to abortion providers. Justice Neil Gorsuch also dissented from the decision to deny the case, though he did not join the opinion written by Thomas.

A spokesperson for Do No Harm expressed disappointment with the court's refusal to hear the case but stated that the group remains committed to challenging government-mandated speech. The organization maintains that medical professionals should not be required to participate in trainings they view as evidence-free or ideologically driven. The Supreme Court's refusal to take up the case leaves the Ninth Circuit's ruling intact, though it does not establish a final legal determination on the constitutionality of the state's requirement.

Sources

Related stories