Mexico's Supreme Court Upholds Criminal Penalties for Medical Negligence
The ruling confirms that health professionals can face criminal charges when a failure to exercise due care results in permanent patient injury.
The Supreme Court of Justice of the Nation (SCJN) in Mexico has unanimously affirmed the constitutionality of federal laws that impose criminal sanctions for injuries caused by medical negligence. The ruling, issued during the resolution of an amparo review, established that penalizing a failure to meet professional standards of care does not violate the principle of legality, the right to work, or the standards of minimal criminal intervention.
The case originated from a legal challenge filed by a neurosurgeon employed by the Mexican Social Security Institute (IMSS). The physician sought to invalidate articles 60 and 291 of the Federal Penal Code after being linked to a criminal investigation in 2022. The investigation followed two spinal surgeries performed in December 2017, after which the patient suffered permanent mobility loss in their right leg. The neurosurgeon argued that the law lacked sufficient precision regarding when medical practice constitutes a crime, claiming this created uncertainty and discouraged necessary medical interventions.
In its decision, the Court clarified that medical practice is an activity of means rather than results. Justice María Estela Ríos González, who presented the project, emphasized that a surgical complication, a lack of healing, or an undesirable outcome does not automatically constitute a crime. Instead, criminal responsibility requires proving that a practitioner failed to observe a concrete duty of care and that this specific omission directly caused the injury.
During the deliberations, some justices debated whether criminal proceedings should be reserved exclusively for cases of gross or inexcusable negligence, suggesting that minor errors might be better addressed through civil or administrative channels. However, the majority rejected the proposal to codify such a distinction, noting that it is the responsibility of the legislature, not the judiciary, to define the parameters of criminal law. Justice Loretta Ortiz Ahlf noted the inherent difficulty in legally distinguishing between levels of negligence in a way that would be practical for judicial application.
The Court further addressed concerns regarding the right to work, ruling that the constitutional protection of professional liberty does not exempt health workers from complying with regulations designed to protect human life and bodily integrity. The justices concluded that the existing penal framework is necessary to address severe harm, and that the existence of civil or administrative remedies does not preclude the use of criminal law when serious, proven negligence occurs.
The ruling does not determine the guilt or innocence of the neurosurgeon involved in the original case. Instead, the Supreme Court has returned the file to the Second Collegiate Tribunal of the Nineteenth Circuit. This regional court is now tasked with reviewing the specific procedural aspects and evidentiary findings to determine whether the criminal proceedings against the specialist should continue or be dismissed.
Sources
- Corte avala constitucionalidad de sanciones penales por negligencia médica en México es-us.noticias.yahoo.com
- ¡RESPALDA CORTE PROCESOS PENALES POR NEGLIGENCIA MÉDICA! notiver.com