Florida Construction Owner Charged With Workers' Compensation Fraud
Authorities allege the contractor underreported company payroll by nearly $1 million to significantly lower insurance costs.
A South Florida construction company owner has been arrested and charged with grand theft, an organized scheme to defraud, and workers' compensation fraud after allegedly concealing nearly $1 million in payroll from his insurer. Israel Carballo, the head of Carballo Group LLC, was taken into custody on November 5, 2026, according to court and state records.
An investigation by the Florida Department of Financial Services revealed that Carballo purchased a workers' compensation policy from NorGuard Insurance, a Berkshire Hathaway company, covering the period from September 26, 2023, through September 26, 2024. During the application process, the company estimated an annual remuneration of $105,000, resulting in a modest annual premium of $9,297.43.
However, a state investigator discovered a massive discrepancy after subpoenaing financial records from five separate companies that had hired Carballo Group to provide labor. Documentation showed that these businesses paid Carballo's firm a combined total of $1,074,278.71 entirely by check for subcontracted labor during the policy year.
Investigators further uncovered that Carballo utilized South Florida check-cashing services to cash the checks received from contractors, a tactic allegedly used to pay workers in cash without reporting the wages. Subpoenaed paperwork and photographs from the check-cashing businesses confirmed his identity as the person conducting the transactions.
According to the arrest affidavit, if the company had accurately reported its actual payroll of over $1.07 million, the appropriate annual premium should have been $109,863. Investigators calculated that the deception defrauded the insurance carrier of $100,565.57 in unpaid premiums.
Public records indicate that Carballo Group LLC was registered as a corporation in 2023 but was later dissolved by the Florida Department of State after failing to file its required annual report in 2025. Following his arrest, Carballo pleaded not guilty through an assistant public defender and was released after posting a total of $12,500 in surety bonds across three counts.
Sources
- Refuerzan operativos de seguridad en zonas comerciales de Poza Rica durante el Buen Fin – Enteratever.COM enteratever.com
- Buscas emprego público? Carballo aproba 18 prazas en diferentes servizos municipais elcorreogallego.es
- Miami Contractor Charged with Underreporting Payroll to NorGuard by $1 Million insurancejournal.com
- He Paid $9,297 for Insurance That Should Have Cost $109,863, Investigators Say. Now the Contractor Faces Fraud Charges yahoo.com
- You Can't Wear White To The Wedding - The Joe Show | iHeart iheart.com