Benni McCarthy Backs Lyle Foster to Break Bafana Bafana Scoring Record
The former international striker believes Foster possesses the necessary quality to eventually surpass his long-standing record of 31 goals.
South African football legend Benni McCarthy has expressed his firm belief that current national team forward Lyle Foster has the potential to become the country's all-time leading goalscorer. McCarthy, who currently holds the record with 31 goals in 80 appearances, identified the 26-year-old Foster as the player most capable of challenging his milestone.
Foster, who plays for the Houston Dynamo in Major League Soccer, has recorded 10 goals in 23 appearances for Bafana Bafana. While he remains 21 goals behind McCarthy’s total, the former international striker emphasized that Foster possesses the unique characteristics and aura required to lead the national team’s attack in the long term.
Despite his confidence in Foster’s ability, McCarthy pointed to a significant tactical shift in modern football that he believes hinders traditional strikers. He noted that the widespread use of inverted wingers has reduced the frequency of crosses into the penalty area, which were once a primary source of scoring opportunities for forwards.
"It is a worldwide thing because when you look at modern-day football, now most teams play inverted wingers," McCarthy explained. "So you don’t get crosses anymore, putting it near post for strikers to make that near-post run. It is difficult to breed strikers when you play inverted on the wings." He contrasted this with his own playing career, where he benefited from natural wingers who provided consistent deliveries into the box.
McCarthy stressed that for Foster and other forwards like Iqraam Rayners to thrive, the team must tailor its tactical approach to their specific strengths. "He needs the service, he needs the team to play for him," McCarthy stated. "You have to play to the strengths of the strikers that you have; when you don’t play to the strength of your strikers, it becomes difficult for them to score goals."
The discussion regarding Foster’s role comes as South Africa continues its campaign for the 2027 Africa Cup of Nations. Bafana Bafana recently secured a crucial 2-1 victory against Kenya in Nairobi, a match in which Foster appeared as a second-half substitute. This win helped the team reclaim the top spot in Group D of the qualifying tournament.
During the recent international window, Foster demonstrated his utility beyond just scoring by providing a key assist in a 2-2 draw against Kenya at the Orlando Amstel Arena. As the national team looks toward future competitions, the debate over how to best utilize Foster’s talents remains a central theme in South African football discourse.
Sources
- Benni tips Lyle Foster to break his Bafana record timeslive.co.za
- Benni McCarthy identifies tactical trend hindering Lyle Foster’s pursuit of Bafana Bafana goalscoring record - 'Most teams play inverted wingers' | Goal.com South Africa goal.com
- Benni Explains Bafana's Striker Problem, Backs Foster soccerladuma.co.za
- Hero Rele’s brace helps Bafana overcome Kenya sowetan.co.za
- Mofokeng double gives South Africa crucial Afcon qualifying win in Kenya africasoccer.com