Skip to content
Technology

Tech Giants Warn Canada Over Proposed Lawful Access Legislation

Major technology companies and privacy advocates are pushing back against Bill C-22, arguing that its surveillance provisions could compromise user encryption.

By 3 min read

Technology companies and privacy advocates are intensifying their opposition to Canada's proposed Bill C-22, known as the lawful access bill, as it undergoes review by the Senate. The legislation, which aims to grant investigative agencies and police services expanded powers to access electronic information, has prompted warnings from industry leaders that the bill could force firms to weaken encryption or withdraw their services from the Canadian market entirely.

During a Senate committee hearing, representatives from Meta and Signal expressed significant concerns regarding the potential for the government to issue secret orders. Signal vice-president Udbhav Tiwari stated that if the company were forced to choose between betraying its users and leaving Canada, it would not compromise the security of its platform. Meta representatives echoed these concerns, noting that the company would be forced to evaluate its options, including the potential removal of services like WhatsApp, if the bill is passed in its current form.

The legislation, which passed the House of Commons in June 2026, includes provisions that would allow the government to compel service providers to build and maintain technical capabilities for law enforcement and intelligence agencies. Additionally, the bill mandates the retention of specific categories of metadata for up to six months. Critics argue that these requirements treat all users as potential subjects of surveillance, regardless of whether they are suspected of any wrongdoing.

Tech companies have specifically highlighted the risks of 'systemic vulnerabilities' or backdoors being introduced into secure systems. While the bill includes language suggesting that providers do not have to comply with orders that introduce such vulnerabilities, critics point to a loophole: the definition of a systemic vulnerability excludes risks that apply only to individuals subject to a specific legal authorization. Privacy experts argue that this exception effectively nullifies the protection, as backdoors created for targeted investigations can compromise the integrity of the entire system.

Apple has also voiced its opposition, emphasizing that privacy is a fundamental human right and that the company will never build backdoors into its products. In a statement, Apple warned that the bill could undermine the security features users expect, particularly as evolving threats like artificial intelligence provide hackers with new tools to exploit cybersecurity weaknesses. Other industry players, including VPN providers like Windscribe and NordVPN, have indicated they may limit their presence in Canada to avoid the bill's data-logging requirements.

Public Safety Minister Gary Anandasangaree has defended the legislation, stating that the government does not intend to mandate the breaking of encryption and characterizing some industry criticisms as incorrect. Despite these assurances, legal experts and privacy advocates remain skeptical. They argue that the bill’s broad scope and the secrecy surrounding government orders raise significant constitutional concerns and could lead to legal challenges regarding the necessity and proportionality of the proposed surveillance measures.

The debate has also drawn international attention, with Ethereum co-founder Vitalik Buterin urging Canadians to contact their senators to defend end-to-end encryption. As the Senate committee continues its review, the outcome remains uncertain. While the committee rarely rejects legislation outright, it frequently proposes amendments, leaving a narrow window for tech companies and civil liberties groups to secure changes before the bill reaches its final legislative stages.

Sources

Related stories