Skip to content
Politics

Supreme Court Justice Rejects PSD Bid for Rio de Janeiro Second Round

Justice Cristiano Zanin ruled that the party improperly used a constitutional action to challenge a previous electoral decision.

By 2 min read

Supreme Court Justice Cristiano Zanin denied a preliminary injunction filed by the Social Democratic Party (PSD) that sought to reinstate a second-round election for governor in the state of Rio de Janeiro. In his ruling, the magistrate did not address the merits of counting votes for candidate Anthony Garotinho, but instead emphasized that the party misused a constitutional instrument as a procedural shortcut.

The legal challenge originated after the Superior Electoral Court (TSE) issued a ruling on October 8 that annulled the votes of Garotinho, a candidate from the Republicans party. That decision allowed Douglas Ruas, representing the Liberal Party (PL), to be officially declared the elected governor during the first round of voting.

Seeking to overturn the effects of the TSE judgment, the political coalition supporting defeated candidate Eduardo Paes turned to the Supreme Court. Justice Zanin pointed out that the electoral court's ruling was already being contested through pending motions for clarification and could eventually reach the high court via an extraordinary appeal.

According to the magistrate, an Arguição de Descumprimento de Preceito Fundamental (ADPF) cannot serve as a parallel route allowing litigants to secure through constitutional action an outcome meant to be pursued within standard electoral litigation. In his written opinion, the justice noted the inadequacy of the chosen legal vehicle as a substitute for regular appeals.

Despite denying the immediate injunction, Justice Zanin's decision does not completely close the door on the broader legal debate regarding the second round. The magistrate ordered the continuation of the procedural steps for the underlying action, allowing time for official statements from the Federal Attorney General's Office and the Prosecutor General's Office.

Additionally, the Supreme Court admitted the Democratic Labor Party (PDT) into the proceedings as an amicus curiae, permitting external legal participation to help inform the ongoing judicial assessment.

Representatives for Eduardo Paes's political coalition released a statement indicating they will await the final resolution of the pending appeal before the electoral court and the final judgment of the constitutional action by the Supreme Court. The group maintains confidence that a second-round runoff should occur if no candidate secures an absolute majority of the votes, as outlined in the federal constitution.

Sources

Related stories