Spanish Court Rules Elevator Stop Must Be Installed for 83-Year-Old Woman
The Provincial Court of Bizkaia ordered a Bilbao residential community to build a dedicated elevator stop for an elderly office co-owner, implementing biometric security to restrict access exclusively to her.
An 83-year-old woman in Bilbao has won a long-standing legal battle granting her the right to a dedicated elevator stop in her residential building, as decided by the Provincial Court of Bizkaia. The conflict involved a six-story building constructed in 1995, where the upper floors consist of residential homes and the first floor is dedicated entirely to offices. The property features only one elevator connecting the lobby to the residential floors, leaving the office level without direct elevator access.
The legal action was brought by the woman, who serves as the usufructuary of an office on the first floor. She sought to invoke the 1995 horizontal property law protecting accessibility for elderly individuals. Under this legislation, individuals over 70 years old can request accessibility modifications without needing an official disability certificate, provided the changes do not compromise the building's structural integrity or architecture.
The community of property owners strongly opposed the installation. They argued that the building was originally designed with independent staircases for the offices to prevent direct mingling between residential and commercial areas, in compliance with Bilbao's historical urban planning regulations. Furthermore, the neighbors expressed concern that opening elevator access to the first floor would inevitably turn the residential lift into a general thoroughfare for clients and employees visiting the various businesses located there.
Although a local court in Bilbao initially rejected the woman's claims, the Provincial Court of Bizkaia partially upheld her appeal after reviewing technical reports confirming that the construction work is entirely viable. The appellate court established that the intervention simply requires opening a doorway through the wall separating the elevator shaft from the office hallway without violating fire safety codes.
To address the community's valid concerns regarding heavy commercial traffic, the court implemented a strict condition. Because the first floor also houses other commercial establishments, such as a speech therapy practice and an insurance brokerage, the judges ruled that the elevator stop cannot become a general entrance for workers or customers.
To enforce this restriction, the court mandated the installation of a biometric recognition system or a similar security mechanism. This technology ensures that the elevator stop will remain exclusively for the 83-year-old plaintiff, preventing any broader commercial use that could strain the residential building's infrastructure.
Legal experts note that while accessibility rights are heavily protected for senior citizens and individuals with reduced mobility, the ruling underscores that such personal benefits cannot be extended to unauthorized third parties or commercial operations sharing the same physical space.
Sources
- Obligan a una comunidad de Bilbao a poner una parada de ascensor solo para una mujer de 83 años | El Correo elcorreo.com
- Obligan a una comunidad de vecinos en Euskadi a instalar una parada de ascensor solo para una mujer de 83 años | El Diario Vasco diariovasco.com
- Fehlentscheidungen: Wer am häufigsten benachteiligt wurde liga3-online.de
- Preußen-Boss einsichtig: Kittner spricht vom „kritischen Moment“ bild.de
- マツコ SNS発の流行に踊らされる人にきっぱり「洗脳されているんだよ!そういう社会なの、今!」(スポニチアネックス) - Yahoo!ニュース news.yahoo.co.jp