South African Labour Court Overturns Suspension and Fires Constable for Theft
A judge ruled that retaining a police officer convicted of stealing R44,000 during an operation violates public interest and judicial standards.
A Gauteng police officer has been dismissed from the South African Police Service (SAPS) after the Johannesburg Labour Court overturned a previous disciplinary suspension and replaced it with immediate termination. The case involved Constable T.C. Lechele, who was found guilty of stealing R44,000 from a resident during an anti-crime initiative.
The incident occurred on August 29, 2024, during Operation Shanela, an initiative in Bronkhorstspruit aimed at enforcing the law and targeting undocumented foreign nationals. According to court documents, Lechele entered a residence and unlawfully took R44,000 belonging to Lagebo Shange. Shange subsequently reported the theft and identified Lechele during an identification parade, after which officers discovered a plastic bag containing the exact amount of stolen cash inside Lechele's personal bag.
Following an internal disciplinary hearing, Lechele was found guilty of improper conduct and breaching the police Code of Conduct. However, the initial disciplinary hearing chairperson imposed a sanction of only a two-month suspension without pay. Discontented with the leniency, the Minister of Police challenged the decision in the Labour Court, arguing that the punishment was irrational and failed to account for the gravity of the offense.
Presiding Judge Makhura ruled in favor of the Minister, stating that keeping an officer convicted of theft who showed no remorse is completely contrary to the public interest. Judge Makhura emphasized that police officers are entrusted with upholding the law and that committing theft while executing official duties constitutes a severe abuse of public trust.
The court noted that Lechele had pleaded not guilty and displayed no appreciation for the seriousness of his actions, despite the conclusive evidence recovered from his vehicle. Furthermore, the judge stated that Lechele's rank and approximately five years of service as a constable did not mitigate the severity of his misconduct, concluding that dismissal was the only appropriate and reasonable sanction.
In a separate law enforcement development concerning police conduct internationally, Western Australia Police Commissioner Col Blanch addressed a disciplinary matter involving Constable Lachlan Costello. Commissioner Blanch stated that Constable Costello was very lucky to keep his job after wearing a vest displaying an inappropriate phrase while arresting a 16-year-old in Geraldton in September 2024.
Commissioner Blanch described the patch as despicable and confirmed that the officer remains on a short leash, warning that any future infractions would result in termination. The disciplinary action against the Western Australian officer also addressed him unlawfully turning off his body-worn camera during the incident, highlighting ongoing global scrutiny surrounding police accountability and professional standards.
Sources
- Suspension overturned: Police constable loses Labour Court battle after stealing R44,000 during crime operation iol.co.za
- Labour Court Sacks Police Constable Who Stole R44,000 During Crime Operation | Joburg ETC joburgetc.com
- 'One thing wrong' will cost obscene patch police officer his job, Blanch says abc.net.au