Skip to content
Politics

Italy Launches New Judge Selection Process Featuring Mandatory Psychological Tests

The Italian Ministry of Justice has announced an examination for 300 ordinary magistrates, marking the debut of compulsory psychometric evaluations for candidates.

By 3 min read

The Italian Ministry of Justice has officially opened applications for a new competitive examination to recruit 300 ordinary magistrates, introducing mandatory psychological and aptitude testing for candidates who reach the oral exam stage. Signed by Justice Minister Carlo Nordio and published in the official gazette, the new call for applications represents the sixth such process initiated during the current legislative term, bringing the total number of advertised positions to approximately 2,300.

Applications for the examination opened online and will remain accessible until December 10, 2026. Eligible candidates must submit their applications electronically using a Level 2 SPID, Electronic Identity Card, or National Services Card, alongside a non-refundable administrative fee of 50 euros processed through the PagoPA system. The written examinations are scheduled to take place from June 21 to June 25, 2027.

The primary innovation in this recruitment cycle is the implementation of psycho-aptitudinal tests, a measure stemming from the 2024 judicial system reform. Candidates who successfully pass the written evaluations in civil, criminal, and administrative law will be required to participate in a collective psychometric testing session before proceeding to their oral examinations. Attendance at this session is strictly compulsory, and any absence will result in immediate exclusion from the selection process regardless of the justification.

Following the written psychometric questionnaires, candidates will undergo an interview conducted by the examination board chairperson alongside an expert psychologist. The Higher Council of the Judiciary established the specific evaluation criteria, which examine five distinct domains: cognitive capabilities, emotional sphere and stress management, relational skills, ethical-valorial dimensions, and organizational competence. The objective of these assessments is to screen out any personal conditions incompatible with exercising judicial functions.

The integration of psychological screening into judicial recruitment has a controversial history in Italy. A similar proposal was initially introduced in 2005 under the second Berlusconi administration but was repealed in 2007. The reintroduction of these evaluations has once again drawn criticism from the National Association of Magistrates, which argued that testing applicants at the recruitment stage could unduly influence the independence of the judiciary.

Beyond the new psychological testing requirement, the examination structure maintains its rigorous traditional format. The written tests consist of three eight-hour papers covering civil, criminal, and administrative law, interpreted through the lens of constitutional and European Union principles. Candidates are permitted to consult basic legal codes and state statutes during these written exams, but they face a comprehensive oral examination program spanning multiple specialized legal disciplines if they advance.

Minister Nordio has repeatedly emphasized that ramping up judicial recruitment is vital to addressing chronic staffing shortages within Italy's court system. Speaking at an event in Cernobbio, the minister noted that the judiciary has historically operated significantly below its standard staffing levels, aggravating delays in court proceedings. By continuously launching new competitions, the government aims to restore full operational capacity to judicial offices nationwide.

Sources

Related stories