Court Rulings Address Tabela Price and Real Estate Contracts
Recent decisions by the Court of Justice of Goiás reinforce legal certainty by upholding standard payment conditions in real estate contracts utilizing the Tabela Price amortization system.
Recent court rulings in Brazil have addressed legal challenges surrounding the Tabela Price amortization system in real estate contracts. Decisions issued by judges Antonio Cézar Meneses and José Ricardo Machado, both from the Court of Justice of Goiás, revoked prior authorizations that had allowed property buyers to replace direct payments to developers with judicial deposits while questioning contract terms.
The legal actions involved properties located in Aparecida de Goiânia, where buyers filed revision lawsuits alleging monthly capitalization of interest through the Tabela Price and cumulative monetary correction under consumer price indexes. Lower court rulings had initially permitted buyers to deposit installment amounts into court accounts and protected them from negative credit reporting. However, the appellate decisions overturned these measures.
According to the appellate rulings, the mere filing of a revision lawsuit does not automatically authorize altering payment methods or substituting direct payments with judicial deposits. The judges emphasized that procedural legislation requires the continued payment of undisputed amounts under originally agreed conditions. Furthermore, the decisions noted that private expert reports presented by buyers were insufficient at this procedural stage to demonstrate unlawful charges without a full evidentiary process.
Attorneys representing the developers highlighted that the rulings align with established standards in the region. Specifically, the decisions reflect the application of a local legal precedent establishing that the use of the Tabela Price in real estate agreements involving companies outside the National Financial System or the Real Estate Financing System is not illegal by itself, provided it is expressly agreed upon by both parties.
The Tabela Price is an amortization system characterized by fixed installment values, barring contractual adjustments. Each payment comprises both interest and a portion dedicated to reducing the principal debt. In the early stages of financing, the proportion of interest is higher, but it gradually decreases over time while the amortization portion increases.
Legal experts noted that these judicial outcomes reinforce legal certainty for real estate transactions by preserving contractual payment obligations during ongoing litigation. While disputes regarding potential irregularities may still proceed on their merits, courts have established that such challenges do not justify interrupting direct financial commitments to developers or relying on judicial consignation without statutory grounds.